Six new Master Sommeliers announced following exam resit

The Court of Master Sommeliers has announced six new Master Sommeliers, all of whom have now passed the gruelling exam twice after a scandal earlier this year stripped 23 newly-crowned candidates of their titles.

Andrey Ivanov, Douglas Kim, Mia Van de Water, Max Kast and Steven McDonald. (Dana Gaiser not pictured.)

Announcing the news yesterday in a Facebook post, The Court of Master Sommeliers announced the six who had passed their qualification, following the Diploma tasting examination which was held on 5 December. The court praised them for commitment and dedication to the industry.

The six new Master Sommeliers, all of whom have now passed the exam twice, are: Dana Gaiser of Lauber Imports in New York; Andrey Ivanov of Bliss Wine Imports in San Francisco; Douglas Kim of Picasso in Las Vegas; Mia Van de Water of Eleven Madison Park in New York; Max Kast of Broadbent Selections in Chapel Hill, North Carolina; and Steven McDonald of Pappas Bros. Steakhouse in Houston. This takes the total number of Master Sommeliers in the world to 279.

All six MS students first passed the tasting exam back in September this year, giving them the title of Master Sommelier. However, in October, they were stripped of the accolade after the The Court of Master Sommeliers found “clear evidence” than an existing MS had revealed the wines that were to be tasted in advance.

The court has never officially named the MS involved but stated that they had been barred from participating in any Court of Master Sommeliers Americas programmes or events, had their membership terminated and had been stripped of their title. It did state that “detailed information” about the wines in the tasting flight was found to have been released prior to the exam, but it did not say whether this information was actually seen by any of the candidates or indeed if it was, how many saw it.

After the decision to void the exam, the court added that it would refund all fees for the exam, hold two retesting opportunities, waive the examination fee for the retest and offer appropriate travel cost assistance for the retest.

It offered all 54 students who took part in the tasting portion of the exam in St Louis, Missouri in September the opportunity to retake the exam. In September’s exam, 23 students who passed were later stripped of the MS accolade.

30 of those 54 candidates chose to resit their exams in December rather than in April 2019. It was not revealed how many of those 30 candidates had already passed the exam.

Speaking to, Steven McDonald branded his experience earlier this year “shocking and devastating” but credits his friends, family and employers for being “so supportive”.

He added: “This feels even better than it did (in September). It’s the craziest and hardest thing I’ve ever gone through in my life. But it’s also bittersweet. A lot of my friends who passed before didn’t make it, and I know how they’re feeling right now. I was relieved and happy but sad at the same time for those who didn’t pass”.

McDonald also told the news site that following the decision on 9 October, people who had received an MS pin in September were not required to return them, but were asked not to display them in public or refer to themselves as Master Sommeliers. Had McDonald failed his exam, he would have had to re-take both the theory and service portions of the exam as well.

One Response to “Six new Master Sommeliers announced following exam resit”

  1. onceAsomm says:

    Of six passing the exam 3 don’t work in restaurants.
    It is fair enough to use your hard earned accreditation to move on with your career, however being allowed to mentor aspiring sommeliers while working for a distributor is too much of a conflict of interests.
    If you work in the trade as i do….it is all too obvious…..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our newsletters

Head of Sales and Marketing

The Lyme Bay Cider Co Ltd

Brand Manager

Hatch Mansfield
Ascot, Berkshire

Southern Regional Account Manager

Speciality Drinks
England, UK

Northern Regional Account Manager

Speciality Drinks
England, UK

Fine Wine Buyer

London, UK

Awards Sales Executive – France

London, UK

Sales Executive / Brand Ambassador

Elixir Distillers
London, UK

Brand Development Executive

Elixir Distillers
London, UK

Sales Administrator

Company details: Advised on application
London W1

London Account Manager

Speciality Drinks
London, UK

Pink Rosé Festival

7th Feb 2019

Wine Paris

11th Feb 2019


London,United Kingdom
11th Mar 2019
Click to view more

The Global Fortified Masters 2018

Deadline : 25th January 2019

The Global Pinot Noir Masters 2019

Deadline : 1st February 2019

Click to view more

Rioja Masters 2018

View Results

The Global Beer Competition

View Results

Click to view more