Parker replacement says he’ll “disappoint”

The Wine Advocate’s new Californian critic Antonio Galloni has said he will disappoint both Robert Parker’s fans and detractors.

Speaking of his upcoming scores in the journal, released later this month, Galloni (left) said in an interview with the San Francisco Chronicle: “There’s a certain percentage of people who just think I’m going to do what Bob did… Then there’s the other people out there who are maybe slightly disenchanted with the direction California wine has taken, and they think I’m going to come in and fix all the ills.”

“Neither of them is true. Everybody’s going to be disappointed.”

Robert Parker announced in February this year that he would retire from tasting and scoring new vintages from California and concentrate on horizontal and vertical tastings of wines from California, Bordeaux and the Rhône.

As reported by db at the time, Galloni joined The Wine Advocate in 2006 and was chosen this year by Parker to handle reviewing the latest releases from the Côte d’Or and Chablis, along with California.

In the interview with the Chronicle, Galloni added that he planned to make the changeover as seamless as possible and hoped winemakers would no longer feel they must appeal to Parker’s palate.

“Maybe this is a catalyst to let people say, ‘I want to make the wine I want to make,’” he stated.

Indeed, db’s California Report 2011 included comments from several wineries suggesting that they were changing their winemaking styles in anticipation of Parker’s retirement.

The phrase “Parker is retiring” was overheard at a number of Napa estates; however, Margaret Rand, writing in the report, pointed out that any immediate changes were not possible to detect during a springtime visit.

“At the moment there is no change of style visible in Napa Cabernet. There is no current trend towards less alcohol, less tannin and more acidity,” she penned.

For more on winemaking trends across California see the drinks business California Report 2011.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our newsletters

Trade Marketing Manager

Boisset La Famille des Grands Vins
London, UK

Senior Export Sales Manager (Beer)

Protege International Group Cyprus Ltd
London, UK


Lanka Premium Beverages
Colombo, Sri Lanka

Marketing Executive

IWSC & Club Oenologique
London, UK

Sales Manager

Alliance Wine
Glasgow, UK

Sales Specialist

London, UK

Sales and Business Development Manager (Spirits)

Protege International Group Cyprus Ltd
London, UK

Business Developer Europe

Copenhagen, Denmark or Haarlem, Netherlands

Wine Sales Administration & Customer Service Assistant

Waddesdon Wine
Waddesdon, Aylesbury, UK

On Trade Sales Manager

Sekforde Drinks Ltd

OenoTrade Portfolio Tasting 2020

London,United Kingdom
26th Feb 2020

Wines of Portugal Annual Tasting 2020

London,United Kingdom
27th Feb 2020

Sangiovese Reset

London,United Kingdom
3rd Mar 2020
Click to view more