Wine must earn its place in the glass

Shifts in consumer behaviour suggest wine’s downturn is cyclical rather than structural, but as beverage choice expands, wine increasingly succeeds only when it connects clearly with food, hospitality and shared experiences, writes Matthew Deller MW.

Last year, I argued on this website that the current downturn in wine should be understood primarily as a cyclical adjustment rather than evidence of structural decline. Pandemic-era inventory expansion, slower economic growth in several major markets and the unwinding of supply chains combined to create a difficult trading environment for producers and distributors. None of those forces suggested that the cultural relevance of wine itself had suddenly disappeared.

Research emerging across several markets during the past year broadly supports that interpretation while also pointing to a second development unfolding alongside the cyclical correction. Wine consumption is changing shape. The category remains part of drinking culture, yet the circumstances in which consumers choose wine are evolving.

Changing demographics in the US wine market

The United States provides one of the clearest illustrations of this shift. Data presented by the Wine Market Council show wine participation declining to approximately 29% of legal-drinking-age adults, representing around 76 million consumers and roughly nine million fewer than two years earlier. The decline is concentrated among older drinkers, with the largest reduction occurring among consumers aged over 60.

This demographic shift complicates the narrative that younger consumers have abandoned wine entirely. Wine Market Council data show that millennials now represent the largest wine-drinking cohort in the United States. The current adjustment therefore reflects generational change as much as shifting consumer preferences.

Survey data among American drinkers provide further context. Health and lifestyle considerations increasingly influence beverage choices, including concerns about calories, sugar and ingredient transparency. These concerns affect all alcoholic categories and shape how consumers evaluate what they drink.

Health awareness and new drinking habits

Research across the wider beverage sector confirms the scale of this shift. A recent beverage outlook published by EY found that 58% of US consumers report actively monitoring ingredients in the beverages they consume, while 66% say they are moving toward drinks perceived to contain less sugar or fewer calories. The same research found that 55% of respondents feel comfortable choosing non-alcoholic beverages in social settings.

These developments place wine within a more competitive beverage environment than the one in which the modern wine industry expanded during the late twentieth century. Many competing drinks communicate sweetness, flavour profile and alcohol level with immediate clarity. Wine labels and wine lists often provide less direct guidance about taste or style.

Industry leaders have noted the consequences of this dynamic. Ben Aneff has described wine as sometimes “losing at the moment of choice” when consumers are unsure how a bottle will taste. Uncertainty about flavour profile can discourage purchase in both retail and restaurant settings.

Wine still thrives around food and social occasions

Research into drinking occasions provides further insight into how wine’s role is evolving. Data discussed at the Wine Market Council conference indicate that wine remains closely associated with meals and shared social occasions. Routine individual drinking occasions appear to be less central to wine consumption than in previous periods.

Evidence from the fine wine segment reinforces the importance of social context. Research conducted by Areni Global across London, Paris, New York, Hong Kong, Shanghai and Singapore found that the primary motivations for buying fine wine relate to personal enjoyment and sharing wine with others. Status signalling and investment play a smaller role than trade narratives sometimes suggest.

Discovery, trust and the pathway into wine

The pathway through which consumers first encounter wine also appears to be evolving. The wine trade has often assumed that appreciation for wine develops primarily through family exposure. Areni’s research suggests that many consumers instead describe a specific moment that sparked their interest.

That moment frequently involves travel, hospitality experiences, formal education or recommendations from friends. Entry into the category therefore often begins through social discovery rather than domestic familiarity. Experiences typically precede deeper learning about wine.

Once consumers develop an interest in wine, purchasing behaviour tends to become more structured. Areni’s research found that many engaged wine consumers maintain relationships with a small number of trusted merchants or advisers. Trust, transparency and reliable access to interesting wines appear repeatedly as reasons for those relationships.

Lifestyle perceptions can still influence behaviour. Research reported by the Wine Market Council indicates that some consumers hold inaccurate assumptions about wine production, including the belief that sugar is commonly added during winemaking. Such misunderstandings demonstrate how easily wine can be misinterpreted when consumers have limited familiarity with the category.

Hospitality environments shape engagement

Participation patterns within wine reveal further nuance. Areni’s research found that women participate in wine education programmes and tasting events in numbers comparable to men. However a smaller proportion progress into regular fine wine purchasing.

Interviews conducted as part of that research suggest that the environments in which wine is served influence participation. Issues such as safety and comfort in drinking venues are frequently mentioned by respondents. These findings highlight the importance of hospitality settings in shaping how different consumers engage with wine.

Hospitality environments also illustrate how demand is evolving. Restaurants and hotels that invest in knowledgeable wine teams and carefully curated wine lists frequently report stronger wine sales. In these settings wine functions as part of a broader hospitality experience built around food and shared time.

Global markets show similar transitions

International markets reveal similar structural shifts. In China a significant proportion of wine consumption historically occurred through institutional entertaining and corporate banqueting. Several industry observers, including long-time importer Don St Pierre, have noted that this form of demand has weakened substantially during the past decade.

Regulatory changes and evolving business culture have altered the role of wine within formal entertaining. At the same time the Chinese market continues to develop through retail, digital commerce and hospitality venues that engage consumers directly. These changes reflect a transformation in how wine is purchased and consumed.

Across markets the pattern appears broadly consistent. Wine continues to perform strongest in settings centred on meals, hospitality and shared experiences. Consumption appears weaker where drinks are selected quickly or without conversation.

Historically wine benefited from habit. In many cultures it functioned as the default drink at the table, supported by social convention rather than explicit decision-making. As beverage choice expands, wine increasingly appears in moments where the decision to drink it is deliberate.

That shift helps explain why certain parts of the market remain resilient even as overall volumes adjust. Premium wine, hospitality-led consumption and shared bottle occasions continue to perform relatively strongly because they align with the contexts in which consumers still choose wine.

For producers and brands the implication is practical. Wine increasingly succeeds where it connects naturally with food, hospitality and shared experiences. In an environment where beverage choice is expanding, wine must earn its place in the glass.

For a deeper look at how younger consumers are actually entering the category, see Matthew Deller MW’s earlier Letter to the editor: how wine gains new drinkers. In that piece, he responds to Alfonso Cevola’s analysis with evidence from IWSR, NielsenIQ and CGA data, arguing that new wine drinkers increasingly discover wine through informal social settings such as casual bars, hybrid wine shops and shared dining experiences, rather than through traditional pathways like family meals or formal hospitality.

Related news

Comment: Asia’s 50 Best Bars 2025 signals a shift in the region’s cocktail hubs

Comment: Diageo shuts down Guinness and Moët Hennessy sale rumours

Comment: how wine brands targeting India can improve their aim