Champagne Masters 2016: the results
This year’s Champagne Masters showed that the quality in the sector is very high. Patrick Schmitt MW takes a look at who took away the top awards at the blind tasting.
CHAMPAGNE IS, of course, an extremely powerful brand. And while that brand strength stems from the region’s history and high-profile supporters, not forgetting the fierce protection of the Champagne name, it also comes from the product itself – which is widely revered for its style and quality.
Indeed, it is the benchmark for sparkling wine. But how good is Champagne today? If one is to judge it by the region’s flag-bearers, then, looking at the results of this year’s Champagne Masters, one can see that the region really is on song. As we have reported in the past, the major houses, or Grandes Marques as they are commonly called, have been on a mission to improve their bread and butter output, the Brut NV Champagnes – a style that makes up more than 80% of production across the entire appellation – and the results of such efforts are really starting to show.
Making these Brut NVs better has been, in part, an amelioration in the quality of the grapes, which is connected to superior viticulture, as well as, in particular, a more sophisticated understanding of when is the ideal moment to harvest.
But for the Grandes Marques especially, who buy in the majority of the grapes they vinify, quality improvements are really a question of superior cellar practices – such as the decision by these famous Champagne makers to use more reserve wine for greater consistency, roundness and complexity, as well as to allow the wine to rest for longer periods in the cellar both on its lees and off them, bringing a desirable bready character, and a more integrated dosage.
Other minor adjustments for improved precision include a reduction in the amount of sugar used in the Brut cuvées, with on average a drop of 20% in dosages over the past 15 years. In combination, this means that any tart, green fizz with a slightly sugary finish is not in evidence today, at least among the famous names that do so much to further the awareness of Champagne worldwide.
So, as the performance of Champagne’s top 10 biggest brands by volume shows, the mightiest names are making some seriously good sparklings, and that’s despite the fact that the majority of the samples assessed this year used base wine from the weak 2011 vintage.
Nevertheless, it should be added that the Grandes Marques do need to be crafting first-rate fizz – not only are the retail and restaurant prices for these cuvées increasingly high, but also the quality and extent of the competition from outside Champagne is rising all the time.
As our Sparkling Masters competition has shown, the output from England, Italy (Franciacorta and Trentodoc) and New Zealand in particular, is increasingly similar in style and quality to Champagne, and more often than not, a touch cheaper than the famous French fizz (though the difference is not as much as one might imagine). But this competition was focused on just Champagne, pitching the biggest brands against each other, and the famous names against lesser-known producers.
Among the sub £30 Non-Vintage Champagnes, no label gained a Gold, but there were plenty of Silver medals, particularly for the cooperative brands, such as Palmer, Jacquart, Montaudon and De Castelnau – all names that are carving out a reputation as good quality entry points to Champagne.
The only Grande Marque Champagne in this price category was Canard-Duchêne, which, with its Cuvée Léonie Brut – a Non-Vintage that benefits from three years ageing in the producer’s cellars – showed why this house is considered a good-value alternative to more famous brands.
Moving into the £30-40 price band, but staying within the Non-Vintage category, the judges were impressed by the quality of Champagne’s largest label: Moët & Chandon, which this year gained a Gold in the blind tasting, up from Silver in 2015. Known among Champagne aficionados for its reductive style of winemaking, Moët’s Impérial Brut NV had an appealing gently sulphurous note, similar to a freshly struck match, combined with a core of ripe yellow fruit and a slightly honeyed character, doubtless from the use of well-stored reserve wine. In essence, it represented a particularly attractive balance.
But it was equalled in quality by a delicious example from De Saint Gall, another cooperative brand, which offered a core of ripe yellow fruits, along with a prominent toasted brioche character and a refreshing, almost bone dry, finish – it was an Extra Brut. However, attracting yet more praise in this category was the sample from Piper-Heidsieck, which, as our first Master of the tasting, became the top example of accessibly-priced NonVintage, benefitting from plenty of fruit and freshness and a lovely toasted bready character along with that classic Champagne chalky taste on the finish.
The quality in this price category was strong across the board, with almost all the entries gaining a Silver or above, and those that didn’t only just missing out – often due to a bruised apple character, suggestive of more oxidative handling, which, while not always unpleasant, can give a bitter finish to the Champagne. Over £40, and we witnessed another star of the day’s tasting, although when the wine was revealed – Charles Heidsieck Brut NV – we weren’t surprised: the house has a long history of producing ‘best-in-class’ Champagnes.
But also in this category was something we weren’t expecting, which was the very high scores for Montaudon, whose Class M rangetopping non-vintage is an impressive fullbodied Champagne with class. Moving beyond £50, it was Taittinger and Lanson that gained the Golds, with the former producer’s Prélude showing the quality of fizz attainable when grapes are sourced from the best grands crus vineyards in Champagne, while the Lanson displayed the complexity possible from extended ageing on the lees for wines that haven’t been through the malolactic fermentation.
In the blanc de blancs category, it was cooperative brands Palmer and De Saint Gall that performed better than the rest, with the latter picking up a Master for its Cuvée Orpale Grand Cru from the brilliant 2002 vintage – giving consumers a fresh chance to sample the delights of this harvest long after most others have sold through not just their 2002s, but 2004s, 05s and 06s.
However, Chardonnay specialist Henriot ran this Champagne close with its Non-Vintage Blanc de Blancs. Meanwhile, while we sampled some very good Blanc de Noirs, none of the entries quite reached the heights of the Brut NVs or Blanc de Blancs, suggesting that Champagne needs Chardonnay to hit the highest notes.
The Vintage and Prestige Cuvée categories showed that a range of recent vintages are producing high-class Champagnes, although when the 2002s featured, they tended to perform better than other years – and recommended in particular is the De Castelnau 2002 for its price-quality-ratio and the Rare 2002 from Piper-Heidsieck, which may be expensive, but is an outstanding fizz.
As usual, the Vintage category delivered the most bang for your buck, with plenty of Golds and Silvers for Champagnes beneath £100. These wines may not have all the accoutrements of the rangetopping Prestige Cuvées, but in terms of what’s in the bottle, a Vintage Champagne from an excellent harvest made by a good producer is hard to beat.
As for the pink Champagnes, this is an area that has dramatically improved over recent years, yielding wines with brightness and, at the top end, persistence, power and many layers of flavour. And few are making greater rosés than Charles Heidsieck and Henriot – even if these are houses better known for their blanc Champagnes. Sparkling wine is a growing category with a wide range of new players, but judging by this year’s competition, Champagne, whatever the style, is still at the peak of the quality pyramid.
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Montaudon Brut||Silver|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Jacquart Brut Mosaïque||Silver|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Palmer & Co Brut Réserve||Silver|
|Champagne Delamotte||Champagne Delamotte Brut||Silver|
|Champagne de Castelnau||Champagne de Castelnau Brut Réserve||Silver|
|Champagne Canard-Duchêne||Cuvée Léonie Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Charles Collin||Cuvée Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Extra Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne Vollereaux||Champagne Vollereaux Brut Réserve||Bronze|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Charles de Cazanove Brut Tradition Père et Fils Tête de Cuvée||Bronze|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||G.H. Martel & Co Prestige Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Château de Bligny Grande Réserve||Bronze|
|Moët & Chandon||Moët & Chandon Brut Impérial||Gold|
|Union Champagne||Champagne de Saint Gall Extra Brut Premier Cru||Gold|
|Champagne Pannier||Champagne Pannier Brut Selection||Silver|
|Lanson International UK||Champagne Lanson Père et Fils||Silver|
|Union Champagne||Champagne de Saint Gall Brut Tradition||Silver|
|Centre Vinicole Champagne Nicolas Feuillatte||Brut Réserve||Silver|
|Champagne Charles Collin||Cuvée Extra Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Charles Collin||Cuvée Charles Brut||Silver|
|Union Champagne||Champagne de Saint Gall Blanc de Blancs||Silver|
|G.H. Mumm & Cie||Mumm Cordon Rouge||Silver|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Cuvée Victoire G.H. Martel & Co Brut Premier Cru||Silver|
|Vranken Pommery Monopole||Pommery Brut Royal||Silver|
|Moët Hennessy||Veuve Clicquot Brut||Silver|
|Chassenay d’Arce||Cuvée Première Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Brut Art Déco||Bronze|
|Champagne Deutz||Champagne Deutz Brut Classique||Bronze|
|Charles Heidsieck||Charles Heidsieck Brut Réserve||Master|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Montaudon Classe M||Gold|
|Champagne Henriot||Brut Souverain||Silver|
|Piper-Heidsieck||Piper-Heidsieck Essentiel Cuvée Brut||Silver|
|Perrier-Jouët||Perrier-Jouët Grand Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Vollereaux||Champagne Rimbaud||Silver|
|Champagne Gosset||Grande Réserve Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne de Sousa||Cuvée des Caudalies||Bronze|
|Champagne Taittinger||Taittinger Prélude Grands Crus||Gold|
|Lanson International UK||Champagne Lanson Extra Age Brut||Gold|
|Champagne Deutz||Champagne Deutz Brut Rosé||Bronze|
|Champagne Gosset||Gosset 15 ans||Bronze|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Millésime 2006||Bronze|
|Champagne de Castelnau||Champagne de Castelnau Millésimé 2002||Gold|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Jacquart Vintage 2008||Bronze|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Palmer & Co Vintage 2008||Gold|
|Champagne Lanson||Champagne Lanson Gold Label 2008||Silver|
|Champagne de Saint Gall||Champagne de Saint Gall Brut Millésime 2009||Silver|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Champagne Victoire G.H. Martel & Co Brut Vieilli en Fût de Chêne 2008||Silver|
|Moët Hennessy||Veuve Clicquot 2008||Bronze|
|G.H Mumm & Cie||Le Millésimé 2009||Bronze|
|Champagne Vollereaux||Champagne Vollereaux Cuvée Marguerite Vintage Brut 2008||Bronze|
|Champagne Henriot||Brut Millésime 2006||Master|
|Charles Heidsieck||Charles Heidsieck Rosé Millésime 2006||Gold|
|Charles Heidsieck||Charles Heidsieck Brut Millésime 2005||Gold|
|Piper-Heidsieck||Piper-Heidsieck Vintage 2008||Silver|
|Perrier-Jouët||Perrier-Jouët Belle Epoque 2007||Silver|
|Vranken Pommery Monopole||Pommery Grand Cru Royal 2006||Silver|
|Champagne de Sousa||Cuvée des Caudalies 2008||Silver|
|Champagne Delamotte||Champagne Delamotte Blanc de Blancs 2007||Silver|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Brut Vintage 2006 Collection Privée||Silver|
|Champagne Pannier||Champagne Egérie de Pannier 2006||Silver|
|Champagne Deutz||Champagne Deutz Brut 2009||Bronze|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Clos du Château de Bligny Cuvée 6 Cépages Brut||Silver|
|Piper-Heidsieck||Piper-Heidsieck Rare 2002||Master|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Jacquart Alpha 2010||Gold|
|Champagne Deutz||Amour de Deutz 2006||Gold|
|Vranken Pommery Monopole||Pommery Cuvée Louise 2004||Gold|
|Charles Heidsieck||Charles Heidsieck Blanc des Millénaires 1995||Gold|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Amazone de Palmer & Co||Gold|
|Champagne Taittinger||Taittinger Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut 2006||Silver|
|Moët Hennessy||Veuve Cliquot La Grande Dame Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Henriot||Cuvée des Enchanteleurs 2000||Silver|
|Champagne VIRGINIE T.||VIRGINIE T. Grande Cuvée 6 ans d’âge||Silver|
|Champagne Deutz||William Deutz 2006||Silver|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Esprit Couture||Silver|
|Chassenay d’Arce||Cuvée Confidences||Silver|
|Centre Vinicole Champagne Nicolas Feuillatte||Palmes d’Or Brut Vintage 2006||Bronze|
|Champagne Deutz||Amour de Deutz Rosé 2006||Bronze|
|Centre Vinicole Champagne Nicolas Feuillatte||Palmes d’Or Rosé Brut Vintage 2006||Bronze|
|Vranken Pommery Monopole||Pommery Cuvée Louise Nature 2004||Bronze|
Blanc de Blancs
|Champagne Le Brun de Neuville||Blanc de Blancs Extra Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Le Brun de Neuville||Blanc de Blancs Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Palmer & Co Blanc de Blancs||Gold|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Jacquart Blanc de Blancs 2009||Silver|
|Les Domaines Jeeper||Champagne Jeeper Brut Grande Réserve||Silver|
|Champagne Le Brun de Neuville||Lady de N. Chardonnay||Silver|
|Champagne Canard-Duchêne||Cuvée Charles VII Blanc de Blancs||Bronze|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Blanc de Blancs||Bronze|
|Champagne Vollereaux||Champagne Vollereaux Blanc de Blancs Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Vieille France Charles de Cazanove Blanc de Blancs Brut||Gold|
|Champagne Delamotte||Champagne Delamotte Blanc de Blancs||Silver|
|Chassenay d’Arce||Blanc de Blancs Millésime 2006||Silver|
|Champagne de Castelnau||Champagne de Castelnau Blanc de Blancs 2003||Bronze|
|Champagne de Saint Gall||Cuvée Orpale Grand Cru 2002||Master|
|Champagne Henriot||Blanc de Blancs||Gold|
|Lanson International UK||Champagne Lanson Extra Age Brut Blanc de Blancs||Silver|
|Champagne Gosset||Gosset Grand Blanc de Blancs Brut||Bronze|
Blanc de Noirs
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne Montaudon Blanc de Noirs||Silver|
|Champagne Charles Collin||Cuvée Blanc de Noirs Brut||Bronze|
|Champagne Canard-Duchêne||Charles VII La Grande Cuvée des Lys||Silver|
|Champagne G.H. Martel & Co||Vieille France Charles de Cazanove Blanc de Noirs Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Palmer & Co Blanc de Noirs||Silver|
|Champagne Deutz||Champagne Deutz Blanc de Blancs 2009||Bronze|
Alternative grape varieties
|Chassenay d’Arce||Pinot Blanc Millésime 2008 Extra Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Rosé Dry Collection Privée||Silver|
|Champagne Pannier||Champagne Pannier Brut Rosé||Silver|
|Lanson International UK||Champagne Rosé Label Brut||Silver|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Palmer & Co Rosé Réserve||Bronze|
|Champagne Collet||Champagne Collet Brut Rosé||Bronze|
|Champagne Vollereaux||Champagne Vollereaux Rosé de Saignée Brut||Bronze|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne de Saint Gall Brut Rosé||Bronze|
|Champagne Gosset||Grand Rosé Brut||Bronze|
|Vranken Pommery Monopole||Pommery Brut Rosé||Silver|
|Moët Hennessy||Veuve Clicquot Rosé||Silver|
|Les Domaines Jeeper||Champagne Jeeper Brut Grand Rosé Réserve||Bronze|
|G.H. Mumm & Cie||Mumm Rosé||Bronze|
|Charles Heidsieck||Charles Heidsieck Rosé Réserve||Master|
|Champagne Henriot||Rosé Millésime 2008||Master|
|Champagne Henriot||Brut Rosé||Gold|
|Piper-Heidsieck||Piper-Heidsieck Rosé Sauvage||Silver|
|Perrier-Jouët||Perrier-Jouët Blason Rosé||Silver|
Design & Packaging
|Champagne Virginie T.||Virginie T. Grande Cuvée 6 ans d’âge||Master|
|Champagne Palmer & Co||Champagne Palmer & Co Blanc de Noirs||Gold|
|Alliance Champagne||Champagne de Saint Gall Brut Rosé Glam’s||Silver|