You are currently viewing the International Edition. You can also switch to the Hong Kong Edition.
Friday 3 July 2015

New book blasts ‘cruel’ Saint Emilion

6th March, 2014 by Rupert Millar

A new book published in France this week has singled out the Saint Emilion classification of 2012 as “illustrative” of many problems with wine in France.



Vino Business” by French journalist Isabelle Saporta, takes a swipe at the “cruel, medieval micro-society”, the “omerta” of big château owners and even critics and reviewers that she says dominate the country’s industry.

Saporta is a journalist with no previous connections to the wine industry but she has written before on intensive agriculture, in 2011 publishing “The Black Book of Agriculture: How we are killing our farmers, our health and the environment”, and in 2009 “Let’s not mince words, eat differently to live better“.

She told La Revue du Vin de France that she was intrigued by the lack of a list of ingredients on a wine label and that had led to a two year investigation into viticulture during which time she came across what she described as, at times, a “detestable” world.

In her interview with LRVF, she describes Saint Emilion in particular as being like the TV show “Dallas”, claiming there is “infinite cruelty” from larger producers towards the smaller ones.

She laments (both in the book and her interviews) how regions like Saint Emilion that were once home to family producers have given way to multi-millionaire investors.

She added that it was easiest to see in Bordeaux as it is the richest region in France but that similar parallels might be drawn in Champagne or even Burgundy.

Regarding the controversial 2012 classification in Saint Emilion, Saporta’s claims will likely throw further fuel on the fire with her accusations that the larger châteaux “fix” the criteria every time to allow them to retain their hegemony.

Alain Moueix, president of the Saint Emilion Grands Crus Association at the time defended the classification telling the drinks business that, as a process, it was “fully transparent”.


Isabelle Saporta

The Times reporting today (6 March) on the story cited Saporta’s claim that taste accounts for only “30% of the marks that determine which wines are placed on the A list” (grands crus classé A, of which there are now four).

Other “surreal criteria”, she says, include the size of the visitor car park, the comfort of the conference rooms and the overall architecture.

Franck Binard, director of the council of Saint Emilion wines, told The Times that the book was “excessive and hollow”.

He did admit that other criteria aside from tasting were used to judge a winery’s suitability for a top ranking but that these were (among other things) the wine’s reputation, the quality of its terroir and the winemaking itself.

Other targets in Vino Business include the châteaux owners who take hefty European Union funds with, says Saporta, no regard for taxpayers as they target big profits.

Pavie, controversially raised to a grand cru classé A status in 2012, is said to have claimed €211,000 of European taxpayers’ money in 2013 and Château La Fleur Saint Georges in Lalande-de-Pomerol, €969,000.

In fact there have been recent complaints from some parts of Bordeaux where at least one mayor has called out estates owned by huge insurance companies and multinationals but which still claim tax breaks intended to support smaller producers.

She adds further that “sycophantic” critics in France allow these estates to get away with such abuses and that many are happy to write positive reviews in exchange for various favours including (in one instance) one critic allegedly demanding €5,000 to guarantee a good mention.

The allegation is similar to that which convulsed The Wine Advocate in 2011 when Jay Miller was accused of taking money in return for high scores.

In her interview with LRVF, Saporta stated that she wanted to see the Institut National de l’Origine et de la Qualité, the INAO, reclaim its role as a “gendarme” in the French wine industry.

“The demarcation of origin is laudable,” she said. “namely to show the richness of the terroirs of France but this idea has been derailed because today the big producers are judge and jury. The INAO must retake control!”

She stressed that the investors she so abhors “know how to make good wine” and that her investigation left her more in love with wine than when she started, particularly for those that “live viscerally for wine”.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

If that's interesting, how about these?

Q&A: John Barbier, the Colorado cook-vintner

“I have never followed a recipe in my life, I’m a man of instinct”, more...

Sud de France launches Wine Hub

An "innovative" tool designed to support wine producers and importers operating more...

Wine thieves go on trial

A gang of wine thieves accused of stealing a million euros worth of wine from more...

Hatch Mansfield – Brand Manager

London, United Kingdom

Competitive salary

Vinexpo: five days 'too much' says organiser

Vinexpo doesn’t need to run for the full five days because no visitor stays more...

Bordeaux 2005: 12 ‘perfect’ wines

Twelve wines have been given “perfect” 100-point ratings in Robert more...

Rise for Haut Bailly in Liv-ex 2015 classification

Liv-ex’s bi-annual “re-classification” of Bordeaux saw Haut Bailly leap more...

Sales Executive - Wines & Spirits Competitions

London, United Kingdom


Burgundy headlines at Acker’s June HK auction

Featuring smaller-sized lots and classic vintages of Burgundy and Bordeaux, more...

World's best beer and wine festivals

Forget Glastonbury, these are the festivals you should be making a beeline for more...

Is Parker wrong about the 05 Médocs?

With no Médoc wines gaining 100-points in Robert Parker’s retrospective of more...

Auction house snaps up online wine specialist

Online auction firm Bid for Wine has been sold to The Fine Art Auction Group in more...

China recognises 'Bordeaux'

China has said it now recognises the term “Bordeaux” as a brand after what more...

Bordeaux 2005: Biggest movers

Expectation surrounding the 2005s is building and pushing up prices for top more...

Warehouse Supervisor

London, United Kingdom

£27,000-£30,000 depending on experience

Shock over wine named 'dung' in German

A row has broken out over a decision by St Tropez's wine co-operative to name more...

The Proust Q&A: Lorenzo Zonin

Italian winemaker Lorenzo Zonin opens up to db about cooking naked, more...

Vinadeis unveils Languedoc 'black diamonds'

One of France’s largest wine producers has launched a high-end Languedoc more...

Business Development Executive

London, United Kingdom

£25-£30K + benefits, depending on experience

China’s Ningxia region launches wine contest

Select winemakers will have the chance to travel to China to learn from its more...

Fire devastates New Zealand winery

A fire has ripped through a New Zealand winery destroying its offices, kitchen more...

The Tour de l'Oc in pictures

A pictorial report of the highs and lows of the Tour de l'Oc cycling challenge more...

Global Wine Buyer

London, United Kingdom


Castel feeds aperitif thirst

Europe’s largest wine producer, Castel, has unveiled a raft of new products more...

Beaujolais pushes for sparkling AOC

Beaujolais is trying to gain AOC status for its sparkling wines which, with it more...