You are currently viewing the International Edition. You can also switch to the Hong Kong Edition.
Friday 3 July 2015

Moueix defends St Emilion reclassification

28th November, 2012 by Gabriel Stone

Terroir should only be given a limited influence in the classification of an appellation, argues Alain Moueix, president of the St Emilion Grands Crus Classés Association.

Speaking to the drinks business about the appellation’s new classification that was approved in September this year, Moueix insisted that a truly transparent approach must be based primarily on results rather than potential. “You can have the best terroir, but if you are not looking after it then the wine may be good but not great,” he maintained.

In part, this disillusionment with a terroir-driven focus has been formed by weary experience with the prolonged legal wranglings that eventually led to the overturn of the earlier 2006 reclassification. “Who can say that one parcel is Grand Cru Classé or Premier Cru Classé in front of a court?” questioned Moeuix.

While acknowledging that valuing a wine by this site-led approach is well established in Burgundy and to a lesser extent in the Médoc, he remarked: “If we had done that more than 200 years ago, then it would be possible.”

Upon taking up the presidency in 2005, Moueix made it a priority to improve the transparency and thoroughness of the process by which wines were awarded Grand Cru Classé status.

From the group of “around 25” members who made up the association when it was founded in 1982, this number has since risen to 59 estates, representing about 600 hectares of St Emilion’s 5,400ha total area. A further five estates qualify for Grand Cru Classé status, but are not members of the association, whose primary aim is to promote St Emilion’s Grand Cru Classé wines.

“Before it was quite opaque in the way it was decided,” Moueix remarked of the system. “But now people who were classified or not classified can know why.”

In addition to inspections by “industry professionals but not from Bordeaux” of the vineyards, winery, cellars and even prices, each estate has its wines blind-tasted by a second independent panel, “some from Bordeaux, but all trained”, according to Moueix.

To qualify as Grand Cru Classé, an estate must satisfy the tasting panel over 10 vintages, while those being considered for Premier Grand Cru Classé must prove their consistency over 15 vintages. Stressing the importance of these combined elements, he noted: “You get some points for it, but you can’t base everything on terroir.”

Today, in marked contrast with Bordeaux’s Left Bank, whose 1855 classification has only seen one major change – the promotion of Mouton Rothschild – since it was created, St Emilion re-evaluates the classification of its own estates every decade. Through this more flexible approach, emphasised Moueix, “we can be sure that estates in the Grand Cru Classé deserve to be there.”

Pointing by way of example to the second growth-equivalent prices now commanded by many of the Left Bank’s “flying fifths”, he flagged up the benefit of St Emilion’s regular reassessment process. “That you have things written in stone is not the way the world works any more,” commented Moueix. “A lot can happen in 10 years.”

For all the controversy provoked by the appellation’s recent reclassifications – although less hotly contested than 2006, the 2012 version has not been without its critics – Moueix praised the system on the grounds that “it pushes everyone to do the best to be classified; if you give your best, then maybe you will get there.”

Above all, he insisted: “The human factor is important – we look at the result. If you base it [classification] on terroir, you base it on potential.” For Moueix, the fact that the most recent classification was so closely aligned with estates’ prices offers further validation. “The market is not stupid,” he remarked.

As for a property such as Valandraud, which raised eyebrows when it leap frogged Grand Cru Classé entirely, being promoted straight from simple Grand Cru to claim a spot as one of the 14 Premier Grand Cru Classé “B” estates, Moueix suggested: “Valandraud is showing that you can get the best out of your soil.”

Despite being confident that the new system offers improved transparency, Moueix admitted: “There is always room for improvement. We will have to take some time in 10 years to look at what we can do.”

Although not areas directly under his jurisdiction, Moueix also indicated that the classifications either side of Grand Cru Classé could benefit from the transparency he has helped to impose at his own level.

Referring to the Grand Cru designation, he noted: “They follow a set of rules, but it is not linked the quality of the wine. The Syndicat of St Emilion is working on it but perhaps it needs to be reviewed.”

As for the process of deciding how estates are ranked within the very top of the appellation’s hierarchy, which is divided into Premier Grand Cru Classé “A” or “B”, Moueix remarked: “The commission decides – I can’t comment.”

A further reaction on the new classification system in St Emilion will appear in December’s issue of the drinks business.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

If that's interesting, how about these?

Hart Davis Hart biggest in US

Chicago-based wine auctioneer Hart Davis Hart is the market leader in the US in more...

Bordeaux 2005: Biggest movers

Expectation surrounding the 2005s is building and pushing up prices for top more...

Castel feeds aperitif thirst

Europe’s largest wine producer, Castel, has unveiled a raft of new products more...

International Business Development Assistant

London, United Kingdom

To be determined, based on the profile and experience of the candidate

Oregon producer takes international view

One of Oregon’s youngest wine estates has partnered with Jackson Family Wines more...

Wine thieves go on trial

A gang of wine thieves accused of stealing a million euros worth of wine from more...

Cockburn’s wins the boat race

Cockburn’s has won the 2015 Barcos Rabelos race, featuring the boats that more...

Sales Executive - Wines & Spirits Competitions

London, United Kingdom


MMD bolsters Italian portfolio with Mazzei

Maisons Marques et Domaines has extended its Italian portfolio with the more...

Californian wine struggling with supply

There is a "growing mismatch" between supply and demand that is badly hampering more...

Is Parker wrong about the 05 Médocs?

With no Médoc wines gaining 100-points in Robert Parker’s retrospective of more...

Wine Buyer

London, United Kingdom

Based on experience

Bordeaux 2005: 12 ‘perfect’ wines

Twelve wines have been given “perfect” 100-point ratings in Robert more...

World's best beer and wine festivals

Forget Glastonbury, these are the festivals you should be making a beeline for more...

Bordeaux wine thieves found guilty

A French court has sentenced 15 men over the audacious theft of $1.1 million of more...

Business Development Executive

London, United Kingdom

£25-£30K + benefits, depending on experience

Parker retrospective boosts 05 Palmer

Château Palmer’s 2005 is the latest wine from that vintage to see an more...

Copa América: Malbec vs Carmenère

Saturday sees Chile and Argentina go head-to-head in football’s Copa América more...

Rise for Haut Bailly in Liv-ex 2015 classification

Liv-ex’s bi-annual “re-classification” of Bordeaux saw Haut Bailly leap more...

London Sales Manager / Key Account Manager

London, United Kingdom

Competitive - depending on skills and experience

Top 10 wines in the UK press

An "epic" Riesling, a "Grecian beauty" that "gobsmacks with opulent tropical more...

Vinadeis unveils Languedoc 'black diamonds'

One of France’s largest wine producers has launched a high-end Languedoc more...

BI offers 2014 imperial collection en primeur

Fine wine merchant Bordeaux Index is offering its clients a 10 imperial more...

Hatch Mansfield – Brand Manager

London, United Kingdom

Competitive salary

China recognises 'Bordeaux'

China has said it now recognises the term “Bordeaux” as a brand after what more...

Santa Rita launching new Irish campaign

Chilean wine producer Santa Rita Estates is spending €500,000 on a new more...