Goose Island wins lawsuit over Bourbon barrel-aged stout beer

AB InBev-owned brewer Goose Island has won a lawsuit after two men sued the company for more compensation after purchasing bottles of its Bourbon County stout which had been contaminated with lactobacillus acetotolerans bacteria.

The bacteria, which is harmless, nevertheless causes sour off-flavours to the develop in the beer. Following the discovery, in 2016, of the contaminant in Goose Island’s 2015 Bourbon County Brand Stout beers as well its Bourbon County coffee stout and barleywine, the company undertook a voluntary refund programme, offering compensation to those that had purchased faulty bottles.

After the refund period had elapsed, in February 2017, Scott Kaplan and Jeff Roach claimed that they had been unable to claim their full refunds and sued Goose Island. They claimed the refund programme was “underpublicised and available for an unreasonably short period of time.” 

Kaplan bought 12 bottles of Bourbon County Brand Stout at US$12.99 per bottle, two bottles of Bourbon County Brand Coffee Stout at US10.99 per bottle and one bottle of Bourbon County Brand Barleywine for $18.99  – a total spend of $196.85.

Roach, on the other hand, purchased 32 bottles of Bourbon County Brand Stout, two bottles of Bourbon County Brand Coffee Stout and six bottles of Bourbon County Brand Barleywine which was estimated to cost between $12.00 to $15.00 per bottle, a total lay-out of around $600.

It is alleged that Kaplan was unable to participate in the refund programme while Roach only received a partial refund.

Goose Island denied that the scheme was under-publicised, but nevertheless sent both men a cheque for $3,000 and $5,000 respectively – the maximum amount recoverable under the Massachusetts statute at issue.

The brewery stated at the time: “Goose Island believes that the fixed submission period for refund requests related to the 2015 Bourbon County Stout release was a reasonable limitation, particularly when no safety or health issue was involved. Nonetheless, Goose Island has granted substantiated requests for refunds on the affected variants after the expiration of the deadlines in some instances. We likewise are willing to provide refunds to Mr. Kaplan and Mr. Roach. Enclosed for that purpose are checks payable to [each], respectively. These payments reflect the maximum amount potentially available to them under M.G.L. ch. 93A, plus additional funds to cover court costs and attorneys’ fees…”

However, the men rejected the cheques and in turn, Goose Island filed a motion to dismiss. The court subsequently found in Goose Island’s favour, agreeing to dismiss Kaplan and Roach’s claim.

The court document stated: “To the extent that the plaintiffs allege that they were injured by the “unfair” refund program, the injury they allege is that they were unable to fully participate in the refund program. Thus, their claim for damages is equivalent to the value of the beer for which they were unable to collect a refund, which is no more than the value of the beer that they purchased. In unconditionally tendering more than the maximum amount that plaintiffs could recover under ch. 93A (treble damages), Goose Island satisfied plaintiffs’ claims under the legal theories pled in Counts I-IV”.

One Response to “Goose Island wins lawsuit over Bourbon barrel-aged stout beer”

  1. Daniel Curtis says:

    Wow. I wish I had these guy’s worries.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please note that comments are subject to our posting guidelines in accordance with the Defamation Act 2013. Posts containing swear words, discrimination, offensive language and libellous or defamatory comments will not be approved.

We encourage debate in the comments section and always welcome feedback, but if you spot something you don't think is right, we ask that you leave an accurate email address so we can get back to you if we need to.

Subscribe to our newsletters

Sales Operations Manager (On Trade)

Berkmann Wine Cellars
London, UK

Wine Sales Executive

Anthony Byrne Fine Wines
Midlands and Northamptonshire

Business Development Executive - London

Jascots Wine Merchants
London, UK

Managing Editor

The Drinks Business Hong Kong
Hong Kong

Techical Administrator

Australian Vintage
Croydon, UK

Events Marketing Coordinator

Speciality Drinks
London, UK

London Business Development Manager

Vine Distribution Services
London, UK

Marketing Assistant

Harviestoun Brewery
London, UK

Business Development Executive

Amathus Drinks Plc
London, UK

Barullo Sessions: Summer Solstice

London,United Kingdom
18th Jun 2019

Canterbury Wine Festival

Canterbury,United Kingdom
22nd Jun 2019

Fruit Focus 2019

East Malling,United Kingdom
17th Jul 2019
Click to view more

The Global Riesling Masters 2018

View Results

Global Chardonnay Masters 2018

View Results

Click to view more