Bordeaux 2017: A year of contrasts

The Bordeaux 2017 vintage represents a year of extreme contrasts that should provide wines that are ‘fascinating to taste’ come en primeur says winemaker Gavin Quinney.

The map charting the frost damage Gavin Quinney compiled earlier this year.

In his now annual deep-dive into the recent growing season and harvest across the Gironde, Quinney – who owns Château Bauduc – notes that despite being destined to go down in history as the “year of the frost”, those growers and châteaux that weren’t wiped out had “every chance of making very good wine.”

The clear result of the spring frosts which everyone was expecting is the vintage is drastically smaller than it was in 2016 (which incidentally was the biggest harvest in a decade for Bordeaux), with volumes forecast to be down 45% on last year and 40% lower than the 10 year average.

In total 2017 should yield some 320 million litres compared to 577m litres in 2016 and it’s smaller even than 2013 which produced almost 400m litres. Overall, 2017 will produce 340m bottles less than 2016.

On the other hand, as he goes on, the cruel reality is that while some areas have been wiped out, some have got by unscathed and those that did survive enjoyed an excellent growing season.

Weather-wise, July was mixed but largely warm and dry (after some blistering heat in June), August hot and dry, there was some welcome rain in early September before warm, dry weather resumed in time for the harvest, which generally had finished by late September or early October.

When picking began the effect of the frost made itself abundantly clear. On the Left Bank in the vineyards of the blue chip châteaux in Pauillac, Saint-Estèphe and St Julien, frost damage was minimal and Quinney notes the vintage looks, “very promising”, with very healthy Cabernet in particular.

The leading estates in Margaux “got off lightly” but large areas in Moulis and Lsitrac were badly damaged, while it was “mixed” in Pessac-Léognan and Graves though harvest conditions were fine for those parcels that were unaffected.

On the Right Bank, meanwhile, Quinney noted that while parts of Saint Emilion, including prestigious properties, “suffered considerable losses of up to 100%”, the plateau above the town where the likes of Troplong-Mondot and Canon are located “fared well” and enjoyed a “bumper crop”.

It was a similar situation in Pomerol where vineyards on the plateau survived far better than those on the lower slopes.

Elsewhere, in Lalande-de-Pomerol, Fronsac, the St Emilion Satellites and, “the engine room of Bordeaux of Bordeaux”, the AOC Bordeaux areas, the damage has been catastrophic in places and quality can be much more variable.

Summing up, Quinney said 2017 was going to prove very heterogeneous but that it should prove a “fascinating experience” tasting the wines en primeur next spring (in the second not first week of April, do note).

As for prices, he echoed the widely known reality that the fall in volume was going to cause a sharp hike in prices of bulk wines but, in a potentially bold prediction, he added: “En primeur prices next year for wines from leading châteaux are surely unlikely to follow suit, however, on the back of the chunky increases for the 2015 and 2016 vintages – regardless of critics and the trade being enthused by the wines next spring.”

We shall see if time proves him right.

His full report with photos and graphs can be read here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our newsletters

Account Manager

Justerini & Brooks
Edinburgh, UK

Senior Partner Manager - eCommerce

Maverick Drinks
London, UK


Liberty Wines
London, UK

HR Co-ordinator

Liberty Wines
London, UK

Director of Sales

Gulf Brands International

Head of Trade Marketing

Lanson International UK Ltd
London W1

Sales Manager

The Drinks Business
London, UK

Customer Development Manager

Love Drinks
London, UK

Junior Brand Manager x2

London, UK

Assistant Brand Manager

Swallow Associates Ltd
Kings Langley, UK

Champagne Masterclass

London,United Kingdom
10th Sep 2018


London,United Kingdom
10th Sep 2018

Cape Wine 2018

Cape Town,South Africa
12th Sep 2018
Click to view more

The Global Beer Competition

Deadline : 22nd August 2018

The Global Malbec Masters 2018

Deadline : 1st September 2018

Click to view more

Cabernet Sauvignon Masters 2018

the drinks business is proud to announce the fifth year of its Global Cabernet Sauvignon Masters

The Global Pinot Noir Masters 2018

the drinks business is proud to announce the fourth year of the Global Pinot Noir Masters, the most extensive competition in the Global Masters series.

Click to view more