Moët Hennessy wins counterfeit case against Acker in Hong Kong

Moët Hennessy has won a court case against wine auction house Acker Merrall & Condit concerning a counterfeit bottle of Krug Collection 1947 presented by the auction house in its sales catalogue in Hong Kong in September 2012.

The Champagne house made the announcement through a press release and said it brought the case before the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region for “trademark infringement and passing off”.

In the final ruling, Acker Merrall & Condit acknowledged and admitted that it infringed upon Moët Hennessy registered trademarks, and passed off a product as a genuine Krug Champagne.

In a statement sent to dbHK, John Kapon, chairman of the auction house, said he is “pleased” to have settled the case amicably and it was “wholly unintentional, infringement of certain of MHCS’s registered Hong Kong trademarks,” stressing that the case involves only one bottle of “tens of thousands” Krug Champagne sold through Acker Asia and its affiliated entities.

“Unfortunately, counterfeits are a reality of life in the fine and rare wine world and despite robust procedures we have in place to minimise the risk of counterfeit bottles entering the marketplace, those procedures are not infallible.

“In this particular case, Krug was able to conclude that the bottle at issue was counterfeit after subjecting it to review and comparative analysis at the domaine. This review and analysis included access to information and records that were, to our knowledge, in Krug’s sole possession and which were not publicly available.”

The ruling details that Acker will conduct reasonably appropriate authentication procedures to ensure all products bearing the Krug trademark and/or any of the other Moët Hennessy Champagne registered trademarks that are to be sold by Acker in its auctions have been produced by and/or ultimately sourced from Moët Hennessy.

In an interview with dbHK recently, John Kapon, chairman of the auction house, claimed Acker has “one of the best and most robust” wine inspection processes despite past allegations of selling counterfeit wines.

The ruling also states that Acker should be restrained from dealing in or with any products bearing the Krug trademark and/or any Moët Hennessy Champagne trademarks which products it knows or ought reasonably to know, not to be of the merchandise or manufacture of the company.

In April at Acker’s New York auction, the auction house sold a few lots of Wolfgang’s amazing collection of Krug Champagne, led by a rare bottle of 1929 Krug Collection in OWC, followed by Krug Collection 1947, 1952, 1959, 1961, 1962, 1966, 1971, 1973, 1976 and 1979.

“This specific action reflects Moët Hennessy’s dedication to the fight against counterfeiting. Moët Hennessy is committed to ensuring its consumers the best quality and security, and is extremely vigilant in all distribution channels,” the release said.

The group works in close collaboration with local and global law enforcement to defend and protect consumers. Moët Hennessy also reinforces the importance for auction houses to respect the authentication processes and certifications of products being auctioned.

This article has been updated on 7 July with comments from John Kapon, chairman of  Acker Merrall & Condit. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our newsletters

Brand Manager

Hatch Mansfield
Ascot, Berkshire

Southern Regional Account Manager

Speciality Drinks
England, UK

Northern Regional Account Manager

Speciality Drinks
England, UK

Fine Wine Buyer

FINE+RARE Ltd
London, UK

Awards Sales Executive – France

Decanter
London, UK

Sales Executive / Brand Ambassador

Elixir Distillers
London, UK

Brand Development Executive

Elixir Distillers
London, UK

Sales Administrator

Company details: Advised on application
London W1

London Account Manager

Speciality Drinks
London, UK

Sales Administrator Customer Service

Ellis Wines
Hanworth, Middx

Pink Rosé Festival

Cannes,France
7th Feb 2019

Wine Paris

Paris,France
11th Feb 2019

IBWSS UK

London,United Kingdom
11th Mar 2019
Click to view more

The Global Fortified Masters 2018

Deadline : 25th January 2019

The Global Pinot Noir Masters 2019

Deadline : 1st February 2019

Click to view more

Rioja Masters 2018

View Results

The Global Beer Competition

View Results

Click to view more