Rosé Masters 2016: the results
Spanning every hue from ballet-shoe pink to almost ruby red, and encompassing a broad range of sugar levels and styles, the rosé category has much more to offer than the pale stuff from Provence – as our Rosé Masters showed.
It should come as no surprise that a category defined only by its colour should contain huge diversity. With wines from the palest of pink to almost ruby red, bone dry to almost cloyingly sweet, reductively handled to barrel-aged, as well as gently spritzy to fully sparkling – there’s little you won’t find from producers of pink wines. However, as with any wine category, some approaches are more successful than others, while commercially, this is a category that sells on appearance – and it’s the pale ballet-shoe pink of Provençal rose that’s attracting the punters at present.
In this year’s Rosé Masters, all styles and quality levels were represented, and, like previous years, certain wines divided opinion. Where debate arose, it concerned what exactly a rosé is, stylistically. For some it is a straightforward, fresh and youthful wine best served straight from the fridge. For others, it can also be a serious product, with structure, made for food and, indeed, laying down.
While a right or wrong answer to such discussion was good fuel for pre-and post-sampling conversation, the tasting was focused on quality – with each judge assessing the wines on show on balance, intensity and complexity, according to price band, whatever the winemaker’s approach.
Nevertheless, the range in both quality and style of rosé proved that this is a category in transition. It appears to be growing up, but not fully mature, as rosé makers experiment with different winemaking approaches.
As Provençal rosé specialist Elizabeth Gabay MW commented on the pink wine category after the tasting: “What we are witnessing is a wine style evolve”. But certain themes emerged strongly this year.
One was the colour variation at the lower end of the price spectrum, particularly compared with higher price bands. Below £15, and rosés ranged from the barely noticeably pink-tinged products to dilute red drinks, prompting judges to wonder whether the term rosé should in fact come with a defined colour spectrum.
At the higher end, over £15, it seemed that all producers wanted one thing: the pale hue of the typical Provençal pink. While this may be the desired appearance for high-spending pink-loving consumers, achieving this light shade wasn’t always to the wine’s advantage – such brief skin contact could leave a wine without the depth and length of flavour to justify higher prices.
Having said that, as judge Hugo Rose MW observed: “The Provençal model is being exported, so other countries are now confident producing a very delicate style of rosé, and a number of other sources are quite successful at this style.”
Sebastian Payne MW concurred, but also lamented the resulting standardisation in rosé appearance and style, while observing the market reality: buyers want a pale product. “I think it’s sad that everyone thinks that their wine has to look like Provençal rosé,” he said.
“At The Wine Society we can sell wines with more fruit, flavour and colour, like Cerasuolo d’Abruzzo, but the commercial pressure to take the colour out is huge.”
Another issue concerned sugar levels. Like all styles of rosé, those over 4g/l were looked at without prejudice and assessed according to their quality level, with the judges searching for balance, aware that there is a large market for sweeter styles.
One judge, Jonathan Pedley MW, said: “The basic requirements for sweet rosé are fresh, bright red berry fruit, and a lot of the more commercial rosés can carry quite high residual sugar levels if they have a decent acidity and not too much alcohol.
“But a number of the sweet inexpensive samples were poor, tired wines that probably never had decent fruit in the first place.”
A similar sense of success and failure in sweet rosé was recorded by Gabay, who said: “I was very surprised at how well some wines handled residual sugar – maybe a lesson that dry doesn’t always equal good.
If the wine was well made the sugar was less obvious. “South Africa’s Vondeling, Château St Jacques’s La Chapelle from the Minervois, and Australia’s Bird in Hand were all lovely examples of good rosés with more sugar [between 3 and 4g/l].
And the Rosé d’Anjou from Remy Pannier was a prime example of how a sweet rosé [16g/l] could also work.
I’m not sure when it would be drunk, but it was juicy and jolly.” On the other hand she added: “The problem with some of the sweeter rosés was that sugar can be compensation for poor winemaking techniques among producers trying to get a pale colour – they are reducing the skin contact time to get a pale colour and then using residual sugar to get the flavour.”
Concluding on this topic, Gabay noted that in southern France, there is an increasing trend for drinking rosé with ice, which alters the balance for sweeter styles.
“Some of the sweeter styles of rosé are being made for serving over ice, which changes the balance, and perhaps we should taste them that way,” she said.
THE ACID TEST
Aside from depth of colour and sugar levels, another point of discussion was acidity, which, of course, was particularly relevant to the sweeter styles, but also key to bone dry rosés.
Pedley commented: “Quite a lot of the rosés were from the 2015 vintage, which [in France] was a warm year, with a good level of ripeness, which means that if you’re not careful you will get low acids… and there were some wines suffering from flabbiness.
“With Côtes de Provence rosé, the flavour of the month, I see this problem quite often, which is partly because of the climate there, but also because of the Grenache used for Provençal rosé, which is an inherently lowacid grape.
“So, those wines have to be well made – you want vibrant red fruit and freshness, and the risk is if you lose the acid then those wines can be flabby.”
On the other hand, he added: “Getting the balance right is crucial, and what you don’t want is any herbaceous character.”
Finally, there was the issue of oak use in rosé. Interestingly, Gabay, who lives in southern France and regularly visits the producers of Provençal rosé, big and small, says there’s a lot more oak use in the famous pink wine region than many believe, and applauds its use to add texture and complexity to the wines.
Similarly, Patricia Stefanowicz MW was impressed with the oaked rosés sampled in this year’s tasting, although she stressed the need for balancing fruit with oak.
“The more expensive dry still wines were, in some cases, absolutely delicious, including those with noticeable oak influence, provided there was enough fruit and acidity to support the oak,” she said.
Taking a different view, however, was Pedley, who said: “I’ve done a big set of tastings looking at premium rosé and I find the oaked wines a bit contrived – in most cases I don’t find the oak integrates with the vibrant fruit I value in rosé.”
For Gabay, the issues surrounding the use of oak in rosé, both to add flavour and texture, is a question of perception – after all, the use of oak, new and old in all its formats, is not just accepted, but soughtafter in whites and reds, particularly at the top end.
“We need to think about what we want from a rosé, and the problem is, rosé is regarded as a simple wine, and it is an intellectual wine,” she said.
Considering the sparkling rosés first, the first Gold was awarded once the entries slipped over the £20 mark, with, significantly, a Franciacorta gaining this accolade in the £20-£30 band, suggesting that the Italian region offers a better quality-to-price ratio than other traditional method pink fizz at these prices, including Champagne and English sparkling.
Moving over £30, it was a Chardonnay dominant Champagne from Comte Audoin de Dampierre that wowed the judges, becoming one of five entries across all categories to earn the ultimate accolade of Master.
Champagnes from the Lanson Group performed exceptionally well too between £30 and £50, with both the Lanson Rosé NV and the company’s Besserat de Bellefon brand picking up Golds.
It was surprising to find a first-rate Tuscan sparkling in this category, with Marchesi Fescobaldi’s vintage Leonia Pomino Rosé awarded a Silver.
Over £50, one would expect high quality, and setting a tough act to follow was Champagne De Saint Gall for its Grand Cru Rosé – awarded a Master – and Lanson’s Extra Age Rosé and Laurent-Perrier’s Cuvée Rosé, which both gained Golds.
Moving to still dry rosés between £10 and £15, the judges were impressed with the benchmark Provençal rosé that was the Pure Mirabeau, as well as the delicious pale pink from Château Brown in Bordeaux – a rosé with brightness and structure due to appearance and whiff of vanilla from its time spent ageing in new oak barriques, tends to divide opinion.
However, this year the judges were all amazed by the power, complexity and, importantly, balance of this wine, which delivered refreshment along with interest. However, Sacha Lichine, the man behind d’Esclans, should watch out – the flagship rosé from Gérard Bertrand, using a blend of Grenache, Mourvèdre, Vermentino and Viognier grown at the company’s Château La Sauvageonne in the Languedoc, is an exceptional wine that rivals Garrus for style and quality.
Indeed, if one wanted proof that rosé can deliver cool refreshment and be a serious drink, then try the top pinks from Bertrand and Lichine.
Rosé: sparkling brut
|La Gioiosa||Rosato Spumante Tradizione Italiana||Italy||Veneto||2015||Silver|
|La Gioiosa||Rosato Spumante||Italy||Veneto||2015||Bronze|
|Tenuta Del Buonamico||Particolare Brut||Italy||Tuscany||NV||Silver|
|Casa Valduga||Casa Valduga Brut Rosé||Brazil||Serra Gaúcha||2013||Silver|
|Champagne Gremillet||Rosé Vrai||France||Champagne||NV||Silver|
|Bolney Wine Estate||Cuvée Rosé||England||Sussex||2013||Silver|
|Leone de Castris||‘Five Roses’ Metodo Classico Brut Rosé, Salice Salentino
|Champagne Jean Diot||Jean Diot Brut Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Silver|
|Champagne Le Brun de Neuville||Tendre Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Bronze|
|Champagne Comte Audoin de Dampierre||Cuvée des Ambassadeurs Rosé Premier Cru||France||Champagne||NV||Master|
|Champagne Lanson||Lanson Rosé Label||France||Champagne||NV||Gold|
|Champagne Besserat de Bellefon||Cuvée des Moines Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Gold|
|Champagne Nicolas Feuillatte||Brut Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Silver|
|Champagne de Saint Gall||De Saint Gall Brut Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Silver|
|Marchesi Frescobaldi||Leonia Pomino Rosé||Italy||Tuscany||2011||Silver|
|Champagne Philipponnat||Royale Réserve Brut Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Bronze|
|Champagne Le Brun de Neuville||Lady de Neuville Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Bronze|
|Champagne de Saint Gall||Brut Rosé Grand Cru||France||Champagne||NV||Master|
|Laurent-Perrier||Laurent-Perrier Cuvée Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Gold|
|Champagne Lanson||Lanson Extra Age Rosé||France||Champagne||NV||Gold|
|Artéis & Co||Artéis & Co Brut Rosé||France||Champagne||2007||Silver|
|Champagne Philipponnat||Cuvée 1522 Rosé||France||Champagne||2006||Bronze|
Rosé: sweet sparkling (over 12g/l residual sugar)
|Villa Sandi||Il Fresco Rosato Spumante||Italy||Veneto||2015||Bronze|
|Bosco Viticultori ‘Canal Grando’||Venezia DOC Rosé Spumante Dry||Italy||Veneto||NV||Bronze|
|Masseria Altemura||Rosamaro Brut||Italy||Apulia||NV||Bronze|
Rosé: still, dry (under 4g/l residual sugar)
|Château de Beaupré||Baron Maxime||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Vondeling||Vondeling Rosé||South Africa||Voor Paardeberg||2016||Silver|
|Castel Frères||Côtes de Provence||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Viña Concha y Toro||Casillero del Diablo Rosé||Chile||Chile||2016||Silver|
|Mirabeau en Provence||Mirabeau Rosé||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Bodegas Príncipe de Viana||Príncipe de Viana Rosada Garnacha||Spain||Navarra||2015||Silver|
|Crush Wines||Bijou Rosé Cuvée Sophie Valrose||France||France||2015||Silver|
|Bodegas Príncipe de Viana||Príncipe de Viana Edición Rosa||Spain||Navarra||2015||Bronze|
|Badet Clément & Co||La Promenade||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Contesa||Cerasuolo d’Abruzzo Contesa DOC||Italy||Abruzzo||2015||Bronze|
|Moulin de Gassac d’Hérault||Fleur du Pays Rosé||France||IGP Pays||2015||Bronze|
|Marqués de Cáceres||Marqués de Cáceres Rosé||Spain||Rioja||2015||Bronze|
|Château Cavalier||Réserve de la Famille||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Château de Beaupré||Villa Tamaris Provence||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Domaine de la Sanglière||Signature S||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Bodegas Izadi||Izadi Larrosa||Spain||Rioja||2015||Bronze|
|Cantina Colle Moro||Montelpulciano d’Abruzzo||Italy||Abruzzo||2015||Bronze|
|Moulin de Gassac||Moulin de Gassac Guilhem Rosé||France||Herault||2015||Bronze|
|Marqués de Cáceres||Excellens Rosé||Spain||Rioja||2015||Bronze|
|Vallone||Brindisi Rosato DOP Vigna Flaminio||Italy||Puglia||2015||Bronze|
|Spadafora||Nero D’Avola Rosato||Italy||Sicily||2015||Bronze|
|Bodegas Casa Primicia||Casa Primicia Rosado||Spain||Rioja||2015||Bronze|
|Château Ksara||Gris de Gris||Lebanon||Bekaa Valley||2015||Bronze|
|Saint André de Figuière||Le Saint André Rosé IGP Var||France||Var||2015||Bronze|
|Viña Pomal||Viña Pomal Rosado||Spain||Rioja||2015||Bronze|
|Mirabeau en Provence||Pure Mirabeau||France||Provence||2015||Gold|
|Château Brown||Château Brown Rosé||France||Bordeaux||2015||Gold|
|Tenuta del Buonamico||Rosato||Italy||Tuscany||2015||Silver|
|Kir Yianni||Akakies Kir Yianni||Greece||Imathia||2015||Silver|
|Famille Sumeire||Château Coussin||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Château Saint Jacques||La Chapelle en Rosé||France||Minervois||2015||Silver|
|Barton & Guestier||Passeport Côtes de Provence||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Domaine Saint Andrieu||Coteaux Varois en Provence||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Williams Chase||Maison Williams Chase Rosé||France||Southern Rhône||`2015||Silver|
|Angels & Cowboys||Angels and Cowboys Rosé||USA||Sonoma County||2015||Silver|
|Bodega Ontañon||Ontañon Clarete||Spain||Rioja||2015||Silver|
|Famille Sumeire||Château L’Afrique||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Rioja Vega||Rioja Vega Tempranillo Rosado||Spain||Rioja||2015||Bronze|
|Château Beaulieu||Cuvée Alexandre Château Beaulieu||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Barton & Guestier||La Villa Barton Côtes de Provence||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Gérard Bertrand||Château La Sauvageonne Volcanic||France||France||2015||Bronze|
|Château de Beaupré||Château de Beaupré||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Bodegas Julian Chivite||Chivite Las Fincas Rosado||Spain||Tres Riberas||2015||Bronze|
|Andeluna Cellars||Andeluna 1300 Malbec Rosé||Argentina||Uco Valley, Mendoza||2015||Bronze|
|Domaine Saint Andrieu||Côtes de Provence||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Famille Sumeire||Château Maupague||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Viña y Bodega Estampa||Fina Reserva Rosé||Chile||VI Region||2015||Bronze|
|Viñas del Vero||Viñas del Vero Colección Pinot Noir||Spain||Somontano||2015||Bronze|
|Château Font du Broc||Château Font du Broc||France||Provence||2015||Master|
|Scala Dei||Scala dei Pla dels Angels||Spain||Priorat||2015||Gold|
|Château Gassier||Le Pas du Moine Château Gassier||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Bird in Hand||D&B Rosé||Australia||Adelaide Hills||2016||Silver|
|Alpha Estates||Alpha Estate Rosé||Greece||Amyndeon||2015||Silver|
|De Bortoli Wines||La Bohème Act 2 Dry Pinot Rosé||Australia||Yarra Valley||2015||Silver|
|Château Léoube||Rosé de Léoube||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Château d’Escarelle||Minuit Rosé – Vendanges Nocturnes||France||Provence||2015||Master|
|Domaines Ott||By Ott||France||Provence||2015||Gold|
|Château Coussin||César à Sumeire Rosé||France||Provence||2015||Gold|
|Caves d’Esclans Sacha Lichine||Rock Angel||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Domaine du Grand Cros||Aurelia||France||Provence||2015||Silver|
|Domaine du Grand Cros||Esprit de Provence||France||Provence||2015||Bronze|
|Château La Sauvageonne||La Villa||France||France||2015||Gold|
|Caves d’Esclans Sacha Lichine Les Clans||Les Clans||France||Provence||2014||Silver|
|Caves d’Esclans Sacha Lichine||Garrus||France||Provence||2014||Master|
Rosé: still, off-dry (over 4g/l residual sugar)
|Remy Pannier||Rosé d’Anjou||France||Loire Valley||2015||Silver|
|Les Grands Chais de France||Bad Eye Deer||USA||California||2015||Silver|
|Vincon Romania||Rosé Cabernet Sauvignon DOC||Romania||Vrancea||2015||Silver|
|Weinkellerei Lenz Moser||Lenz Moser Selection Zweigelt Rosé||Austria||South Austria||2015||Bronze|
|DFJ Vinhos||Portada Winemaker’s Selection||Portugal||Lisboa||2015||Bronze|
|Zimmermann Graeff Müller||Invenio||France||Languedoc||2015||Bronze|
|Villa Yambol||Villa Yambol Rosé||Bulgaria||Thracian Valley||2015||Bronze|
|Bodegas Esteban Martin||Marqués de Alfamén||Spain||Carinena||2015||Bronze|
|Zimmermann Graeff Müller||O&E Zinfandel Rosé||USA||Languedoc||2015||Bronze|
|Vignerons de France||Aimery||France||Languedoc||2015||Bronze|
|Felix Solis Avantis||Caliza||Spain||Do Mancha||2015||Bronze|
|Felix Solis Avantis||Viña Albali||Spain||Castilla -La Mancha||2015||Bronze|
|Vincon Romania||Busuioaca Bohotin Rosé Far Niente||Romania||Vrancea||2012||Bronze|
|Zimmermann Graeff Müller||Jack & Gina||USA||California||2015||Bronze|
|Castello Vicchiomaggio||San Jacopo||Italy||Tuscany||2015||Bronze|
CLICK HERE TO SEE A RUNDOWN OF THE TEN BEST PERFORMING PINK WINES IN THE COMPETITION, INCLUDING TASTING NOTES.