Arsenic case against US wineries thrown out

A case against several leading Californian wine brands alleging that their wines contain “extremely elevated” levels of arsenic has been dismissed by a judge.

Wine-cork-and-bottle

The case against 28 US wineries was dismissed by a judge at California’s Superior Court

Lawyers representing four plaintiffs in the case of Doris Charles et. al. vs. The Wine Group, Inc., et. al. filed the lawsuit on 19 March 2015 against 28 producers including Treasury Wine Estates, Trinchero, Fetzer Vineyards and Bronco. It claimed that the wineries were violating state law by “knowingly” producing, marketing and selling wines with traces of inorganic arsenic up to 500% more than what is considered the maximum acceptable limit in California.

At the time, the Californian Wine Institute branded the case an “irresponsible publicity campaign” designed to “scare the public into thinking that wine is not safe to consume, which is patently untrue.”

“Arsenic is prevalent in the natural environment in air, soil and water, and in food”, it said in a statement. “As an agricultural product, wines from throughout the world contain trace amounts of arsenic as do juices, vegetables, grains and other alcohol beverages. There is no research that shows that the amounts found in wine pose a health risk to consumers.”

This week the case was dismissed by a judge in California’s Superior Court in Los Angeles, a year after it was filed, according to reports by Wine Spectator. 

The case had claimed that the wineries had violated California law by not disclosing the presence of arsenic in their products. Allegations were based on claims by Beverage Grades, a Denver laboratory, that it found inorganic levels of arsenic in 83 brands that were higher than what the EPA allows in drinking water.

However the judge upheld that the wineries were following current labelling regulations by clearly warning consumers about the dangers of alcohol, and that there is no current regulatory requirement to disclose the presence of trace arsenic in wine. Defendants also argued pointed out that there has been no government ruling that the trace levels of arsenic found in wine pose a health risk.

Releasing a statement on the case dismissal, the Wine Institute said Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Shepard Wiley had granted winery defendants “motion to dismiss an unfounded claim that trace amounts of arsenic in wine pose a health threat to consumers”.

“Private attorneys filed the meritless “arsenic in wine” complaint in March 2015″, it continued. “Wines from around the world all contain trace levels of arsenic – as do fruits, vegetables, grains, seafood, juice and other beverages. The FDA has been monitoring the arsenic content in food and beverages for more than 20 years. Arsenic is naturally occurring in the environment in air, soil and water and is present in virtually all foods and beverages. For additional information, visit www.arsenicwinefacts.com.”

Plaintiffs have said that they will appeal the decision.

One Response to “Arsenic case against US wineries thrown out”

  1. stacey tindell says:

    How can i get in touch with Doris Charles? Thank you in advance

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please note that comments are subject to our posting guidelines in accordance with the Defamation Act 2013. Posts containing swear words, discrimination, offensive language and libellous or defamatory comments will not be approved.

We encourage debate in the comments section and always welcome feedback, but if you spot something you don't think is right, we ask that you leave an accurate email address so we can get back to you if we need to.

Subscribe to our newsletters

Supply Chain Assistant

Speciality Drinks
London NW10 7SF, UK

On-Trade Regional Sales Manager

Anthony Byrne Fine Wines
West Midlands & Northants

Supply Chain Co-ordinator

Speciality Drinks
London NW10 7SF, UK

Logistics Team Leader

Speciality Drinks
London, UK

Key Account Executive

Berkmann Wine Cellars
London, UK

Assistant Operations Manager

Speciality Drinks
London, UK

Technical Manager

North South Wines
West Drayton, UK

Key Account Manager

MMI Maldives
Maldives

TERRITORY SALES MANAGER

Eurowines Limited
Harrogate, UK

Business Manager - Impulse

Australian Vintage
Croydon, UK

Exclusive Masterclass: Chablis on Tour

London,United Kingdom
29th Apr 2019

Vinexpo Bordeaux

Bordeaux,France
13th May 2019

London Wine Fair 2019

London,United Kingdom
20th May 2019
Click to view more

The Global Organic Masters 2019

Deadline : 19th April 2019

The Global Grenache Masters 2019

Deadline : 26th April 2019

Click to view more

The Global Riesling Masters 2018

View Results

Rioja Masters 2018

View Results

Click to view more