You are currently viewing the International Edition. You can also switch to the Hong Kong Edition.
Sunday 5 July 2015

Palate Press accuses MacLean of copyright infringement

17th December, 2012 by Lucy Shaw

US online wine magazine has accused Canadian wine writer Natalie MacLean of copyright infringement on her website

Natalie MacLean

Canadian wine writer Natalie MacLean

MacLean, whose website boast over 145,000 members, publishes a paid for subscription newsletter offering “exclusive wine reviews” for US$2.10 a month.

In addition to her own reviews, she includes reviews by professional wine writers often without attributing them to a publication or providing a link to the review.

Instead, they are all accredited to “Vintages Wine Catalogue,” a Liquor Control Board of Ontario publication that runs fully accredited reviews, including information on the author, date, and publication.

“There is a simple phrase for this practice in which MacLean has engaged – copyright infringement.

“Just because someone is writing about wine rather than politics or foreign affairs does not absolve him or her from adhering to journalistic ethics,” Palate Press wrote in an open letter addressing the issue on its website.

“Intellectual property theft is a scourge on journalism and cannot be tolerated. We cannot sit idly by while a colleague brings discredit upon any of us by flouting ethical standards,” it added.

Responding to the accusations, MacLean replied on the Palate Press website:

“I am in the process of adding the information, including names and publications, beside the quotes that has been requested, beginning with the most recent reviews and going backwards.

“I welcome and listen to feedback from both colleagues and readers and make changes as a result, including all that has been requested in this case.”

Screen grab from

Screen grab from

The online magazine contacted a number of the wine writers who have been featured on MacLean’s site, including Jancis Robinson MW, James Halliday, Jamie Goode, and The Wine Advocate’s new editor-in-chief Lisa Perrotti-Brown MW, none of whom had given their permission for her to include their content.

On learning reviews from her Purple Pages website had been used on MacLean’s site without her permission, Palate Press reports that Robinson was “horrified.”

“I am horrified, Natalie. Not just by the general lack of proper attribution, but by the appropriation of reviews from Purple Pages, which is a members-only publication.

“Please take steps to remove all reviews appropriated from Purple Pages immediately,” Robinson wrote to MacLean.

“There is a qualitative difference between a retailer’s quoting a review for sales purposes and a fellow wine commentator’s publishing it on their own personal website,” Robinson later told Palate Press.

The magazine is currently investigating allegations that MacLean has asked a number of wineries to subscribe to her website before she will accept their wines for review.

5 Responses to “Palate Press accuses MacLean of copyright infringement”

  1. I am not sure that Natalie Maclean has infringed the copywright of fellow wine writers if their work is registered in the ‘Vintage Catalogue’ of the Ontario Control Board, as claimed. While I agree with Jancis Robinson that there is a qualitative (and one might add ethical) difference between a retailer quoting a review for sales purposes and a fellow wine writer quoting another’s review on his/her website- this is an ethical standards issue separate from copyright infringement . It seems that Palace Press are confusing the two by lumping them together. I remember that ethics and intellectual property were a hornet’s nest for litigants when i was a student at Gray’s Inn in the late ‘sixties. it would be good to hear the informed opinion of a certain wine-writing QC now retired.

  2. A follow up piece by our publisher, David Honig (who is a practicing attorney), and Gary Thomas has been published on Palate Press:

  3. Chris Miller says:

    I think there must be an algorithm in there that will show us the future of wine marketing and branding and taste.
    Snooth + CellarTracker x Lot18 ÷ Wines Till Sold Out x Campogate ÷ Jay Miller – Brunellogate + Robert Parker Jr selling Wine Advocate + Natalie Mclean + Jancis ÷ Palate Press & all this times Gary Vee has gotta equal something important.

    I am sure I’m missing some important elements to the equation so don’t trust the outcome.

  4. Michael – you should check copyright laws in Canada.This is a clear theft of intellectual property prohibited by law in our beautiful country. Chris the equation is simple – take a journalist’s intellectual property without payment, acknowlegement or even permission and you commit a crime – and then if you go on to charge people a fee for accessing this? You could now face a class action suit. Check the Heather Robinson case which was won (hard won after many legal battles but won) against the major print publications in this country when they took journalists’ work and published it without compensation or permission online.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

If that's interesting, how about these?

Top 10 Negroni spots in London

As the Campari Red Night District takes over London's Shoreditch, we round up more...

Suntory's exquisite 3D-printed ice cubes

As far as advertising campaigns go, this collection of miniature ice cube more...

Fine dining resto to serve wine on tap

Proving that the trend in the UK has spread beyond casual dining venues, fine more...

World's most extravagant wineries

With Château Margaux preparing to unveil its new winery and cellar, designed more...

Top 10 wine brands 2015

In a year that saw major shifts in the global wine market, the drinks business more...

10 richest people in the UK drinks trade

As The Sunday Times Rich List 2015 reveals the wealthiest individuals in more...

PR Senior Account Manager/Director

London, United Kingdom

Depending on experience

Top 10 new products

This month's top releases include a Champagne tankard designed by Pol Roger, more...

Top wines of Bordeaux 2014

The 10 best wines of the Bordeaux 2014 vintage as voted for by Liv-ex’s more...

Top 10 ways to reuse a wine bottle

If you are anything like the db team, it won't take long to amass a collection more...

Supplier Relationship Manager

London, United Kingdom

Top 10 worst estates for en primeur returns

Using Liv-ex's data, db rounds up the worst 10 châteaux for en primeur more...

Fascinating facts worth knowing about beer

Think you know everything about beer? This collection of beer-related facts more...

Top 12 Australian fine wines

Australian fine wines have made the headlines of late. But what are the names more...

Hatch Mansfield – Brand Manager

London, United Kingdom

Competitive salary

How to become a 'wine expert' in four hours

A doctor of psychology has devised 10 simple steps which he claims can set you more...

Top 10 US craft breweries

The Brewers Association has released its annual list of the biggest US craft more...

Diageo appoints North America president

Deirdre Mahlan, Diageo's chief financial officer, has been announced as the more...

UK Sales Manager

London, United Kingdom

Top 10 banned alcoholic drinks

The drinks trade has seen its fair share of drinks banned from public more...

Top 10 architectural wonders of the wine world

You don't have to look far to find stunning examples of architectural prowess more...

The London Wine Fair in pictures

From red trews and foie gras macaroons to 2CVs, wine on tap and temporary more...

Warehouse Supervisor

London, United Kingdom

£27,000-£30,000 depending on experience

Top 10 estates for en primeur returns

db rounds up the 10 best Bordeaux estates for en primeur returns on more...

Top 10 modern wine drinker stereotypes

From Rioja lovers to Champagne quaffers, the drinks business has more...