France suffers ‘ultimate affront’ in tasting competition

A team of French professionals suffered the “ultimate affront” of finishing in 11th place in a wine tasting competition, well behind the UK team, while a plucky Zimbabwean team forced Italy into an ignominious last place.

The competition was French publication La Revue du Vin de France’s fifth annual Tasting World Championships which, this year, were held at Burgundy’s Château de Gilly on Saturday 14 October.

With China having won a surprise victory last year, this year’s winners were from Sweden with the British team coming second and the Luxembourg team third.

Also in the top 10 finishers were New Zealand, Finland, Spain, Hungary, Quebec (Canada), China and Poland.

A total of 24 teams from across five continents competed this year, with South Africa, the US, Russia and Andorra among those in attendance and with Brazil, Denmark and the Netherlands competing for the first time as well.

The teams tasted 12 wines in total, six white and six red, and had to identify the country or region of origin, main grape variety, vintage and, if possible, the producer.

The wines included some classic French wines from Bordeaux and Burgundy, German Riesling and Spanish Garnacha, as well as a couple of trickier examples such as a Nebbiolo from Mexico and a Lebanese Cabernet Sauvignon.

Although excellent at identifying the few French wines being poured, Philippe de Cantenac from LRVF told The Times that the French team, which included Château Margaux’s commercial director Aurélien Valance, had flopped when it came to identifying wines from elsewhere in the world.

He told the paper: “Every French person thinks they are a connoisseur but we only know our own wines and not those from other countries.

“It’s the same with Italy and Spain and all wine producing nations. They only drink their own wines. Countries like Sweden and the UK are far more open.”

French magazine L’Express wailed that if it was bad enough Sweden had been shown to have the finer palates, in an “ultimate affront”, the “Tricolores” had finished behind the UK as well.

This marks at least three years where the French team has failed to win the competition but they can console themselves that they didn’t do as badly as Italy whose team came dead last.

In 23rd place was a team from Zimbabwe competing for the first time and it marked the first time that two African countries competed at the event too.

The story of the four young sommeliers; Tongai Joseph Dhafana, Pardon Taguzu, Tinashe Nyamudoka and Marvin Gwese (who all work in South Africa) has attracted a growing amount of international interest.

Their cause has been particularly championed by Jancis Robinson MW who also helped fundraise for the team though her site,

The four men (who work at La Colombe, Test Kitchen, Aubergine and Cape Grace Hotel) are also to be the focus of a new documentary by Warwick Ross – the director behind 2013’s ‘Red Obsession’.

Still in production, the film is tentatively scheduled for release in early 2019.

The winning Swedish team was made up of:

Torgny Almgren
Jerker Delsing
Richard Granberg
Ulf Palmnäs

The British team comprised:

Christopher Nelmes
Christopher Spencer
Vincent Dulhoste
Warwick Thurtell

And the Luxembourg team was:

Guy Bosseler
Jules Hoffelt
Hervé Amann
Valentin Niro

5 Responses to “France suffers ‘ultimate affront’ in tasting competition”

  1. Tom Gable says:

    How about publishing a list of the wines tasted in the competition?

  2. ed says:

    Where did US finish or a full list of all teams

  3. Shaji Mathew says:

    So, what were the wines entered in the competition?

  4. Kwispedoor says:

    “Ultimate Affront” – haha! Anyone that knows anything about blind tasting knows that if they tasted a different set of wines the next day, the results would be very different. It really isn’t such a train smash.

  5. Winer says:

    Do you people know how to Google? Jeez.

    24. 45 points Italy
    23. 46 points Zimbabwe
    22. 50 points Belgium
    20. 53 points Andorra
    20. 53 points Portugal
    19. 57 points Monaco
    18. 61 points Russia
    17. 62 points Switzerland
    15. 70 points USA
    15. 70 points Netherlands
    14. 71 points South Africa
    13. 73 points Denmark
    12. 74 points Brazil
    11. 75 points France
    9. 78 points Poland
    9. 78 points China
    8. 86 points Quebec
    7. 90 points Hungary
    6. 91 points Spain
    5. 93 points Finland
    4. 94 points New Zealand
    3. 100 points Luxembourg
    2. 107 points UK
    1. 115 points Sweden


    Cave des Amandiers, Fully Fendant 2014 Valais, Switzerland
    Clos St-Vincent, Le Clos 2016 Bellet, France
    Friedriech Becker, Sonnenberg Riesling 2011 Pfalz, Germany
    Ken Forrester, The FMC Chenin Blanc 2015 Stellenbosch, South Africa
    J C Boisset, Trezin 2015 Puligny-Montrachet, France
    Gini, La Frosca 2013 Soave Classico, Italy


    L A Cetto, Reserva Privada (labelled Réserve Privée in France) Nebbiolo 2012 Valle de Guadelupe, Mexico
    Ch Kefraya 2012 Kefraya, Lebanon
    Dom La Fourmone, Le Poète 2014 Vacqueyras, France
    Palacios Remondo, Propriedad 2012 Rioja, Spain
    Ch Figeac 2009 St-Émilion, France
    Niepoort 1987 Port, Portugal

Leave a Reply to ed Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our newsletters