Top 10 wine scandals

17th August, 2011 by Rupert Millar

Mudslinging in Dallas sur Rhône

Family in-fighting is never pretty. In January last year accusations began flying around as arguments over money and inheritance turned nasty.

Guy Arnaud, a producer in Châteauneuf-du-Pape, divided his 51-hectare estate between his three daughters. The 17ha they each received were valued at €500,000 per hectare and would be granted to them when he died.

Two daughters were happy with the arrangement but the third, Carole Perveyrie-Arnaud was not.

She wanted access to her plot immediately, not upon her father’s death. She and her husband sued Arnaud for €200,000 and when she still couldn’t get at her land she spread rumours that her father was breaking appellation laws and blending wines from other AOC into his Châteauneuf-du-Pape.

The police were called in but no evidence of wrongdoing was discovered and the case was dropped.

The family met to resolve the situation and to appease Carole she was granted access to 8ha with a value of €3.5m.

However, she decided afterwards that the deal wasn’t good enough, “I came out the loser” she complained in a statement and threatened further legal action to get her hands on some of the buildings on the estate.

Share4K

Share22

12 Responses to “Top 10 wine scandals”

RentCaine says:

August 17, 2011 at 7:20 pm

What happened to all of the Red Burgundy blended with Rhone and Algerian wine for decades or more?

Reply
Rupert Millar says:

August 18, 2011 at 9:46 am

@RentCaine I gave it a mention near the bottom when talking about the same thing happening in Bordeaux. I was a bit hard-pressed to find any solid examples in the time I had to write this. If you know of any books or articles that cover the subject let me know and I’ll be happy to add a little bit extra.

Reply
Maureen Downey says:

August 18, 2011 at 7:27 pm

Rupert – you seem to be missing a few.
What about the Ponsot wines that were never made that Acker refused to pull from an auction, until Laurent Ponsot walked into the auction room? The consignor has still never coffed up the source of the wines. And what of the dismissal of the producers personal claim to the auction house that the wines weren’t made in moving forward with the sale? In any other industry some oversight might have resulted in a different outcome than – nothing.
That is about as blatant as it gets: Producer says wine never made, auction house dismisses the communication and proceeds with sale until producer walks into the room, consignor refuses to reveal source.

There are plenty more. I see them, and the very fake wines traded as a result almost monthly. But no one really seems to care. And those who perpetrate the fraud are still thriving in business and have even maintained reputable standing in the industry….

I think the biggest scandal – is the lack of scandal. The lack of investigation, and lack of prosecution. The lack of spine in the industry to stand up to the fraudsters and stop the commerce of fake wines. The lack of caring by guys that have been defrauded out of millions – but wont admit it so they can save face & keep thier seats at the big party tables. This denial is the biggest scandal of all.

Reply
Bob Scharpf says:

August 19, 2011 at 5:53 am

Nearly all the scandals seem to occur in Europe. I am pleased to see that California has not make the top ten. In fact, what if any are wine scandals that have been reported from the wine regions of the West Coast? There must be some.

Reply
Bob Scharpf says:

August 19, 2011 at 5:58 am

No reply

Reply
Rupert Millar says:

August 19, 2011 at 8:26 am

@Maureen I quite agree. As for the Acker auction I had forgotten about that and I accept that some scandals will be missing (that’s the problem limiting yourself to only 10 but I have cheated by mentioning other scandals in the texts). Thanks for reminding me though,

@Bob It does seem funny that I couldn’t find anything for California, although I did try believe me. If you hear of any please let me know. I suppose that Gallo’s Red Bicyclette was sort of a scandal for the region/US. Although the wine was made in France the guys at Gallo must have twigged that Pinot Noir was not the main grape. Don’t tell me they couldn’t tell the difference between Pinot and Syrah or Grenache.

Rupert

Reply
Karl Laczko says:

August 21, 2011 at 10:05 am

No Californian scandal? What about Sausalito Cellar’s Mark Anderson and his alleged (since he’s now changed his plea to not guilty) arson of the Wines Central warehouse in Vallejo in 2005?
A similar fraud, without the warehouse arson (but only because they never had the wine in the first place), in the UK resulted in the jaiing of Paul Craven and Oseghale Hayble of Bordeaux Wine Trading Ltd earlier this year.
Throw away the keys…..

Reply
Tim Pawsey says:

August 21, 2011 at 4:35 pm

Thanks for such an informative piece, Rupert …
Fake icewine, either made or bottled in China, continues to pose a major problem for legitimate Canadian and German producers. Most agree that by far the majority of ‘icewine’ sold in China (amounting to several million dollars worth annually) is bogus, sometimes little more than sugared water.
The good news is that most fake bottles are pretty easy to spot as, like the Mt. Tauch knock-offs, their labels usually involve some sort of excruciating typo or spelling mistake and rarely make reference to Canada’s VQA appellation law, although the original Mission Hill fake labels (among the first that brought the practice to light) were convincingly copied right down to the typeface. British Columbia’s Wine Institute now lists certified BC VQA producers by vintage on its website. Any Canadian wine using the legally correct term of ‘icewine’ (one word) has to be VQA origin certified.
The bad news is that most Chinese buyers don’t know any better—and likely won’t for some time yet.
Extensive WS piece here: http://www.winespectator.com/webfeature/show/id/44430

Reply
wino says:

August 22, 2011 at 3:42 am

What about the Australian winery, Kingston Estate, adding silver nitrate to their wines to improve aroma debacle of 2010?

Reply
Jon Hesford says:

August 22, 2011 at 8:41 am

To be truthful, the reasons there are few scandals in the list from California is that half of the things that caused the scandals in Europe are permitted in California anyway.

Reply
Pieter Malan says:

August 29, 2011 at 11:33 am

High on my list of scandals is the fake Champagne that KWV exported to Panama (1988) with Moet & Chandon labels printed by a local South African printer. LVMH and interpol investigated but all was nicely swept under the carpet. Following that was the KWV adding greenpepper to their Sauvignon Blanc shaming the whole South Africa wine industry.
The Billionaire’s Vinegar by Benjamin Wallace was a skillful recording of the Jefferson bottles but there are many more scandals for him to dig up.

Reply
arnie backbacon says:

December 1, 2011 at 11:30 pm

The biggest fraud in canada is the VQA itself- being a small winery owner and winemaker here are the facts
regarding the Vintners Quality Assurance.
There is no assurance of anything- period. The wine that boasts a VQA label could have come from anywhere
on the planet- the universe in fact- if that was possible.
Here is how it works- first off you have to plunk down $ 1000.00 cdn to join the fraud that is the
VQA – once you have a wine you feel you want VQA status- you send it to the LCBO lab for analysis- just to
make sure you’re not poisoning someone- then as part of a $300 fee the wine moves on to a tasting panel of
possibly cashiers, stockboys, product “experts”. industry wine writers…… really anybody who they can find who has
a few hours to kill- no real experience necessary as far as i can gather- this is who decides on whether or not
your wine is worthy of the VQA moniker- let me retreat a little- the wine you send in, could be from anywhere….
literally, i could go to my local lcbo, buy 3 bottles, come back to my winery and transfer the wine to my bottle and
submit it to VQA for approval. that is the honest truth. it gets better. if the “expert” panel decides you are worthy then
you are permitted to put VQA on your label. in fact in 2 places on the bottle- they are real sticklers about this, because
after all it’s now a VQA wine. here’s the better part- once you have approval there is absolutely no follow up- the
wine that you bottle going forward is a moot point- no checks- no balances- the wine that you plunk that bogus
VQA label on is never authenticated. nothing-zero- a bulk wine brought in by “constipation brands” from god
knows where, could now be sitting on a shelf at your local LCBO proudly displaying the VQA SEAL of ASSURANCE.
Not only is the VQA a complete fraud- it’s a legislated fraud. the LT. Governor of Ontario instituted an award of
excellence for the wine industry- 2011 being the first year- the catch is, all wines submitted have to be VQA wines-
which could come from anywhere on the planet- given the lack of scrutiny by the VQA i have just explained. Sadly,
there are 100’s of great Ontario wines which never get to the public palate because of this stranglehold .
i just received an email from the Brock University Oenology Dept. announcing a pinot noir challenge in march 2012.
Please submit your VQA wines- my heart sunk- i have 3 great pinots to enter- 2 of which won awards in the 9th
annual pinot noir challenge in california last winter. over 400 pinots from around the world- sadly, i can’t enter my
100 % ontario grown and made wine- in my own province- in my own country- why? it’s not VQA- because, you
might gather by now- in VQA wine ” there is no truth”.

Reply