Napa winery sues its consultant for $1.6m

28th May, 2014 by Lucy Shaw

Chateau Potelle in the Napa Valley is suing its consultant for US$1.6m after he failed to produce a “cult” wine that met the estate owner’s standards.

Jean

Jean-Noel Fourmeaux of Chateau Potelle in Napa is suing his wine consultant for $1.6 million for breach of contact and negligence

According to the Napa Valley Register, court records filed at the Napa County Superior Court state that Chateau Potelle’s owner, Jean-Noel Fourmeaux, hired consultant Denis Malbec in 2012 with the aim of creating a “cult” wine that could sell for US$200 a bottle.

The wine, designed to show off Chateau Potelle’s new tasting room, was to be made from grapes from a vineyard on the Mount Veeder AVA of the Napa Valley and was due to be called “Fourmeaux” after the estate’s owner.

Though with high hopes often comes great disappointment and, rather than the “cult” wine he desired, 4,000 gallons of the wine, which had to be filtered five times, is currently being sold in the bulk market.

Fourmeaux is suing Malbec alleging breach of contract and negligence, and is also accusing the Healdsburg winery where the grapes were crushed, Medlock Ames Vintners, and two of its winemakers of negligence. Malbec denies the allegations.

“The wine is not of quality that I can use,” Fourmeaux told the Napa Valley Register, accusing Malbec of not taking “appropriate action” when the level of volatile acidity in the wine began to rise in November 2012.

The lawsuit claims that Malbec unintentionally accelerated the volatile acidity formation and then left the winery to go on a 10-day holiday, returning in January to a wine that was “irreparably compromised.”

As reported by the Napa Valley Register, Malbec and the other defendants are seeking arbitration – a less formal process used to settle a legal dispute. Fourmeaux opposes the motion. A hearing is set for this Thursday.

8 Responses to “Napa winery sues its consultant for $1.6m”

  1. guillemet says:

    Difficult and strange case. It’s hard to believe that nobody rang the bell, as situations generally don’t deteriorate so dramatically. It would be interesting to know the details of the case and to propose solutions.

  2. Lenny Pepperidge says:

    Pretty clear that they were trying to amp up the VA (which Parker is notorious for likiing) in order to get a big score and the process got away from them.

  3. Steve Felten says:

    You pays your money and you takes your chances.

  4. Mauricio says:

    The question is, as a Winemaker Consultant, what is the right thing to do if you are not getting paid (on time) by the owner and also the winery is not getting paid for their services.
    We all know that many wineries all around the world don’t usually pay all their bills on time.
    You let the wine go bad?
    You finish the wine and then sue the owner for the money he owes you?

    In my opinion Mr. Malbec’s reputation is on the line here and I think he did not manage the situation correctly. If you ask me, I would of act like a professional and finish the wine and then deal with the late fees.

  5. Rick Aldine says:

    There is wayyy more to this story than what is briefly presented in print. Denis is a great Winemaker and Medlock Ames is a first class facility with competent staff. Hold your judgement of all parties until the entire affair is vetted in detail.

    • Robert says:

      I agree with Rick. There is more to this than what is printed and we shouldn’t jump to conclusions until we have all the facts.

  6. Some winemakers get the wines to the extreme, so called “extreme winemaking” read here
    http://extremewinemaking.ca/doing-wines-with-high-va/

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to our newsletters

Job vacancies

FINE WINE SALES ADMINISTRATOR

Davy's Wine Merchants
London, UK

Business Development Manager - On Trade

FINE+RARE
Central London, GB

Regional Sales Manager

Swallow Associates Ltd
Home Based: North-West England, UK

London Account Manager Role (Full Time)

LITTLE BIRD GIN
Home based with UK travel. , GB

Sales Operations Manager

Bibendum PLB
London, UK

Digital Marketing Executive (online content & community manager)

Corney & Barrow Limited
London E1W (near Tower Bridge), UK

Store Manager – Premium Drinks

Amathus Drinks PLC
London, UK

On-Trade Regional Sales Manager

Anthony Byrne Fine Wines
London and the South East, UK

Wine Sales – Northwest England

Gerrard Seel
North West England

Senior On-Trade Sales Manager – English Sparkling Wine Company

COREcruitment
London based with national travel, UK

National Account Manager – RTM – On Trade

COREcruitment
Home based with frequent UK travel

Sales Account Manager - Wine

COREcruitment
London, Devon, Manchester, Liverpool, Farnham, Cambridge, UK

The Global Sparkling Masters 2017

Deadline : 14th June 2017

The Global Syrah Masters 2017

Deadline : 14th June 2017

The Global Malbec Masters 2017

Deadline : 14th June 2017

The Global Beer Masters 2017

Deadline : 1st August 2017

Click to view more

Global Chardonnay Masters 2016

Now in its fourth year, the competition will identify the best Chardonnay from all around the world in every price range.

The Asian Cabernet Sauvignon Masters 2017

the drinks business Hong Kong announces its first year of The Asian Cabernet Sauvignon Masters.

Rioja Masters 2016

Now in its fifth year, the competition will recognise and reward the finest Riojas on the world stage.

Fortified Masters 2016

Now in its third year, The Fortified Masters will reward the best fortified wines on offer.

Click to view more